Key West, Florida, has lovely beaches, fun nightlife, and tasty food. But there is more to enjoy. There are amazing ice cream shops that offer fantastic frozen treats. Forget the regular chain stores for now. Explore the local ice cream places that make Key West a real paradise for ice cream lovers.
10 Must-Try Ice Cream Delights in Key West
In Key West, you can find many amazing ice cream flavors. There are tropical fruit sorbets and rich chocolate treats. Whether you like classic vanilla or want to try something new, you will love these ten ice cream options. They will satisfy your sweet tooth and make you want to come back for more. Get ready for a fun ice cream adventure in the heart of Key West!
1. Tropical Mango Tango Sorbet
Escape to a tropical paradise with every spoonful of this cool sorbet. It is made with ripe mangoes that are full of flavor. This sorbet is a great way to chill on a hot day. Its smooth texture and sweet and tangy taste will take you to a sunny beach, reminding you of the warm Florida sunshine.
You can enjoy this sorbet by itself to taste the mango. If you want, you can also have it with a scoop of coconut ice cream for some creaminess. For a special treat, add a little honey and some chopped macadamia nuts on top.
2. Key Lime Pie on a Stick
Experience the famous tastes of Key West in a fun and easy snack. Picture a smooth key lime pie filling. It has a zesty citrus flavor and is coated in rich white chocolate before being frozen. Every bite gives you a great mix of sweet and tart. This captures the charm of this favorite dessert.
The stick makes it simple to enjoy this snack as you walk through the lively streets of Key West. The mix of creamy, tangy, and chocolate flavors is hard to resist. It’s a cool and fulfilling dessert that will make you want more.
3. Coconut Cream Gelato
Indulge in the rich and creamy coconut cream gelato. It is made with fresh coconut milk and a bit of sweetness. This dessert gives you a taste of the tropics. The homemade creamy flavors and smooth texture will take you to a beach paradise. Each bite is as refreshing as a light ocean breeze.
To truly enjoy it, have it on its own. This way, you can appreciate the delicate coconut flavor best. You can choose a cup or a cone. For a special treat, try it in a warm waffle cone.
4. Bahama Mama Chocolate Swirl
This ice cream is a delicious mix of chocolate and rum flavors. It takes inspiration from the popular Bahama Mama cocktail. Think of rich chocolate ice cream mixed with a Caribbean rum sauce. This gives it a fun kick. The chocolate sauce adds even more richness. Each bite is a special treat.
Whether you love chocolate or like trying new tastes, you have to try this ice cream. The mix of rum and chocolate is hard to resist. Plus, the smooth and creamy texture will make you want more.
5. Sea Salt Caramel Crunch
Try this amazing ice cream that has the right mix of sweet and salty flavors. Picture a caramel ice cream with swirls of sea salt caramel and crunchy caramel bits. The salt makes the caramel taste even better, making it hard to stop eating.
The crunchy caramel pieces give a fun texture, making each bite full of different flavors and feelings. This is the kind of ice cream that will leave you wanting more.
6. Caribbean Rum Raisin
Calling all rum and raisin fans—this is for you! Picture a creamy vanilla ice cream mixed with the warm tastes of Caribbean rum. Juicy raisins soaked in rum bring a tasty chewiness to every bite.
This classic ice cream flavor gets a special touch from Key West with the Caribbean rum. It is the ideal dessert to enjoy on a nice evening while walking down Duval Street.
7. Sunset Sherbet Blast
Get ready to enjoy refreshing flavors that come from the colorful sunsets of Key West. This sherbet mixes tropical fruit flavors. It gives you a taste that is both tangy and sweet. The bright colors are just like a Key West sunset, making it a treat for both your eyes and your taste buds.
This sherbet is a light and cool dessert. It is perfect for people who want a lighter treat. It is also a good choice for those with dietary needs because it is naturally fat-free.
8. Pirate’s Bounty Vanilla Bean
This ice cream is simple, but it is not ordinary. Think of creamy vanilla bean ice cream made with real vanilla beans. This gives it a strong flavor. It is a perfect base for adding your favorite toppings. However, it tastes great by itself too.
You will see lots of vanilla bean specks in the ice cream. This makes it look good. It also gives a burst of flavor with every wicked lick.
9. Southernmost Toffee Indulgence
Calling all toffee fans! This ice cream mixes creamy vanilla with crunchy toffee bits covered in rich milk chocolate. Each bite gives you a nice balance of creaminess, crunchiness, and chocolaty flavor.
The toffee bits add a fun crunch to the smooth vanilla ice cream. You will love it whether you have it in a cup or a cone. This ice cream will fulfill your sweet needs.